Is Kopi Luwak Halal?

This report provides a comprehensive analysis of the permissibility of Kopi Luwak (civet coffee) within Islamic law, examining both the technical jurisprudential rulings and the broader ethical principles of the faith. While a narrow legal argument for the halal (permissible) status of Kopi Luwak exists, it is contingent upon a strict set of verifiable conditions that are rarely met in practice and contested by other Islamic scholars. Major religious bodies in producing nations like Indonesia and Malaysia have deemed the coffee permissible, provided the excreted beans remain intact, are capable of germination, and are thoroughly washed to remove all impurities. However, this ruling is not universally accepted, with other authorities declaring the product forbidden due to its contact with filth.

More critically, the report finds that the modern Kopi Luwak industry is overwhelmingly defined by practices that violate the Islamic ethical requirement of tayyib (wholesome, good, and pure). The widespread and documented cruelty inflicted upon Asian palm civets—including confinement in small, unsanitary cages, forced and unnatural diets, and resulting psychological and physical trauma—renders the product ethically untenable. This systematic abuse means that even if a bean could be ritually purified, the process of its creation is tainted by sin, leading to the conclusion that it is haram li ghayrih (forbidden due to an external factor). Compounding this is the pervasive fraud within the industry, where coffee from caged, abused animals is routinely mislabeled as “wild.” For the conscientious Muslim consumer, the confluence of legal doubt (shubuhat) and severe, systemic ethical violations makes avoidance of Kopi Luwak the most prudent and spiritually sound course of action.

1. The Genesis of a Controversial Delicacy: Understanding Kopi Luwak

To comprehend the complex debate surrounding Kopi Luwak, one must first understand its unique production method and the stark evolution from a traditional, foraged good to an industrialized, often cruel, commodity. This context is fundamental to appreciating the legal and ethical dilemmas that follow.

1.1 The Natural Process: From Coffee Cherry to Excreted Bean

Kopi Luwak is coffee produced from beans that have been ingested and subsequently excreted by the Asian palm civet (Paradoxurus hermaphroditus).¹ The process begins when the civet consumes ripe coffee cherries. As the cherries pass through the animal’s gastrointestinal tract, they are subjected to a unique combination of acidic, enzymatic, and fermentation treatments.¹ The civet’s digestive enzymes permeate the coffee cherry’s endocarp, breaking down storage proteins into shorter peptides and altering the amino acid composition.¹ This biological modification is purported to be the source of the coffee’s famed characteristics, particularly its reduced bitterness and distinct aroma, which fully develops during the final roasting process.¹

Historically, the discovery of Kopi Luwak is tied to the colonial period in Indonesia. In the 19th century, Dutch colonialists established vast coffee plantations but forbade local farmers from harvesting the coffee for their own use.¹ These farmers observed that wild civets were eating the coffee cherries and leaving the undigested beans in their droppings. They began collecting, cleaning, and roasting these beans, creating a beverage that was born from ingenuity and necessity.¹ This origin story forms the basis of the romanticized, naturalistic narrative that still dominates the marketing of Kopi Luwak today.

1.2 From Forest Floor to Factory Farm: The Industrialization of a Niche Product

The traditional method of producing Kopi Luwak involved foraging for the feces of wild civets on forest floors and coffee plantations.¹ This was a labor-intensive process with a naturally limited yield. However, as global demand surged and Kopi Luwak gained a reputation as one of the world’s most expensive coffees, the economic incentives shifted dramatically.¹ The high price point created a powerful profit motive that led to the abandonment of traditional methods in favor of industrial-scale production.

This modern approach involves the capture of wild civets, which are then confined in small, often barren, battery cages.¹ Instead of foraging for a varied diet, these animals are typically force-fed an unnatural and unhealthy diet consisting almost exclusively of coffee cherries to maximize the output of beans.¹ This fundamental shift from a naturally occurring, found product to a mass-produced commodity is the primary driver of the profound ethical crisis at the heart of the Kopi Luwak industry. The economic pressure to increase supply has directly caused the collapse of ethical production standards.

1.3 A Question of Quality: Scientific and Industry Scrutiny of the “Luwak Effect”

Producers and marketers claim that the superior quality of Kopi Luwak stems from two factors: the civet’s innate ability to select only the ripest, most flawless coffee cherries, and the flavor-enhancing properties of its digestive process.¹ However, these claims are heavily disputed within the specialty coffee community. The Specialty Coffee Association of America (SCAA) has stated that the “general consensus within the industry…it just tastes bad,” with many professionals viewing it as a novelty item or gimmick rather than a high-quality coffee.¹

Scientific research further complicates the narrative. Some studies suggest that the unique flavor profile may not be due to digestion at all, but rather the civet’s preference for a different, naturally sweeter species of coffee, Coffea liberica, when available.⁷ The scientific evidence for flavor enhancement via digestion remains unconvincing.⁷ This gap between the romantic marketing narrative and the reality of the product is significant. The industry appears to be selling a story that is largely disconnected from its modern, industrialized practices and whose core quality claims are scientifically and professionally unsubstantiated. To make matters worse, the market is rife with fraud, with studies indicating that a significant portion of Kopi Luwak sold is either adulterated with regular coffee or entirely counterfeit.⁷

---

2: The Core Jurisprudential Debate: Purity, Impurity, and Purification in Islamic Law

The question of Kopi Luwak’s permissibility in Islam centers on complex principles of ritual purity (taharah) and impurity (najasah). Understanding these foundational concepts of Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh) is essential to navigate the various scholarly opinions.

2.1 Foundational Principles: Defining Halal, Haram, and Najis

In Islam, all foods and drinks are governed by the principles of halal (lawful or permissible) and haram (unlawful or forbidden).⁸ The default ruling for all things is permissibility, unless there is a clear prohibition in the Qur’an or the authentic traditions of the Prophet Muhammad.⁹ The Qur’an commands believers to consume that which is

halalan tayyiban—not only lawful but also good, pure, and wholesome.⁹

Central to this discussion is the concept of najis, which refers to substances deemed ritually impure or filthy. According to Islamic law, certain substances are inherently impure (‘ayn najis), a category that includes feces, urine, blood, pigs, and dogs.¹³ Any object that comes into contact with an

‘ayn najis can itself become impure.¹⁵ Since Kopi Luwak beans are, by definition, passed through a civet’s digestive tract and mixed with feces, their contact with an impure substance is the primary source of jurisprudential controversy.

2.2 The Crucial Distinction: ‘Ayn Najis vs. Mutanajjis

The linchpin of the argument for Kopi Luwak’s permissibility lies in a critical legal distinction between two types of impurity:

• ‘Ayn Najis‘: An object that is impure in its very essence. The feces of the civet fall into this category.¹³ Such an object cannot be purified.
• ‘Mutanajjis‘: A pure object that has become contaminated by contact with an ‘ayn najis. For example, a clean garment that has been soiled with urine.⁹

The majority of Islamic scholars who have issued a fatwa permitting Kopi Luwak do so by classifying the coffee bean as mutanajjis.⁹ In this view, the coffee bean is originally a pure (

tahir) plant product. Its journey through the civet’s digestive system contaminates it with feces, but it does not transform the bean itself into an inherently impure substance. This classification is crucial because, unlike an ‘ayn najis object, a mutanajjis object can potentially be restored to a state of ritual purity.

2.3 The Path to Purity: The Fiqh of Taharah (Ritual Cleansing)

An object classified as mutanajjis can be purified (taharah) through a process of thorough washing that removes all traces of the impurity.¹⁶ According to Islamic jurisprudence, for the purification to be valid, the cleaning must eliminate the taste, smell, and color of the contaminant.¹²

In the specific case of a seed or bean that has been ingested and excreted, classical jurists stipulated additional conditions for it to be considered purifiable. The bean must emerge from the animal’s digestive tract hard, solid, and intact, without being broken or structurally compromised.⁹ Furthermore, it must retain its viability, meaning it could still germinate if planted.⁹ If the digestive process were to “cook” or fundamentally alter the bean’s essence, or if it were to become soft and absorbent, it would be considered to have transformed into an impure substance and would no longer be purifiable.²⁰ This creates a theoretical legal pathway to rendering Kopi Luwak

halal, but it is a pathway heavily dependent on specific, physical conditions that may not hold true for every bean and are impossible for an end consumer to verify. The legal framework, developed for a “found object,” struggles when applied to an industrial process where the state of each bean is unknown.

---

3: The Verdict of the Ulama: A Comparative Analysis of Global Fatwas

Applying these jurisprudential principles, Islamic religious authorities around the world have arrived at differing conclusions, creating a landscape of conflicting fatwas on Kopi Luwak.

3.1 The Indonesian and Malaysian Consensus: Permissible Under Strict Conditions

Given that Indonesia and Malaysia are major producers of Kopi Luwak, the rulings from their national religious bodies carry significant weight.

• Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI): In a landmark 2010 fatwa, the MUI declared Kopi Luwak to be halal.²¹ Their legal reasoning rested on the classification of the coffee bean as
  mutanajjis (contaminated by impurity) rather than ‘ayn najis (inherently impure). They concluded that as long as the beans are thoroughly washed to remove all traces of feces, they are permissible to produce, sell, and consume.¹⁷ This ruling provided crucial religious legitimacy for the country’s lucrative Kopi Luwak industry, bringing “relief to farmers”.²²
• Malaysian National Fatwa Council (JAKIM): Following a similar line of reasoning, the Malaysian Fatwa Council also ruled the coffee to be permissible, but with explicit conditions.⁹ Their ruling stipulates that for the coffee to be
  halal, two criteria must be met: 1) The coffee beans must be in their original state—hard, intact, not broken or hollow—and still capable of growing if planted. 2) The beans must be thoroughly washed to remove all najis.⁹ The council also mandated that Kopi Luwak must obtain official Halal certification from JAKIM or a state religious council before it can be marketed to the public.⁹

3.2 Dissenting Voices: Rulings of Impermissibility and Doubt

The Indonesian and Malaysian view is not universally shared. Several prominent scholars and schools of thought have issued prohibitive rulings.

• Sheikh Ahmad Hujji al-Kurdi (Kuwait): A member of the Kuwait National Fatwa Committee, Sheikh al-Kurdi issued a fatwa declaring Kopi Luwak impermissible. His ruling classifies the product as najis, adopting a stricter interpretation that the contact with feces renders the bean unpurifiable.⁹
• Datuk Sheikh Abdul Halim Abdul Kadir (Malaysia): Before the official council ruling, the then-President of the Malaysian Ulama Association, Datuk Sheikh Abdul Halim Abdul Kadir, stated publicly that Kopi Luwak is haram (forbidden), demonstrating that dissenting opinions existed even within producing nations.⁹
• Shi’a Jurisprudence: The general position within the Shi’a school of thought is that Kopi Luwak is haram and najis.¹⁷ This view typically considers the bean to have become ritually unclean from its internal contact with the animal’s waste, making it impermissible for consumption.

The divergence in these rulings highlights a key dynamic: the permissive fatwas have emerged from the primary producing nations, where there is a significant economic interest in the Kopi Luwak industry. In contrast, prohibitive rulings tend to come from regions and schools of thought with no economic stake. This pattern suggests that local economic context may influence which jurisprudential arguments are given precedence.

Table 1: Comparative Summary of Key Fatwas on Kopi Luwak

Issuing Body/Scholar	Country/School	Ruling	Legal Classification	Key Conditions / Rationale
Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI)	Indonesia (Sunni)	Halal (Permissible)	Mutanajjis	Beans are intact, can be washed thoroughly, and are capable of growing if planted. 17
Malaysian Fatwa Council (JAKIM)	Malaysia (Sunni)	Halal (Permissible)	Mutanajjis	Beans are intact, not broken/hollow, can be washed, and must obtain Halal certification. 9
Sheikh Ahmad Hujji al-Kurdi	Kuwait (Sunni)	Haram (Impermissible)	Najis	Considers the product to be inherently impure and not subject to purification. 9
General Shi’a Opinion	Shi’a Islam	Haram (Impermissible)	Najis	The bean is considered ritually unclean due to its contact with feces inside the animal. 17
Datuk Sheikh Abdul Halim Abdul Kadir	Malaysia (Sunni)	Haram (Impermissible)	Najis	Stated the coffee is forbidden, aligning with a stricter interpretation of impurity. 9

Ultimately, the conditional nature of the permissive fatwas places an unverifiable burden of proof on the consumer. A person buying a bag of roasted Kopi Luwak has no way of knowing if the beans were originally intact, viable for germination, or washed according to strict Islamic standards. This transforms a seemingly clear legal ruling into a practical uncertainty, creating a significant area of religious doubt (shubuhat).

---

4: Beyond Permissibility: The Ethical Dimension of Halalan Tayyiban

Even if one were to accept the conditional jurisprudential argument for Kopi Luwak’s ritual purity, the product faces a far more profound challenge when evaluated against the holistic Islamic principle of halalan tayyiban—that which is both lawful and wholesome. The tayyib aspect encompasses ethics, goodness, and purity of process, an area where the modern Kopi Luwak industry catastrophically fails.

4.1 The Islamic Mandate for Animal Welfare

Islam has a deep and explicit tradition of compassion towards animals. The Qur’an and the Hadith (Prophetic traditions) are replete with injunctions commanding Muslims to show mercy to all living beings and to avoid cruelty.²⁵ The Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is reported to have said, “A good deed done to an animal is as meritorious as a good deed done to a human being, while an act of cruelty to an animal is as bad as an act of cruelty to a human being”.²⁵ Another well-known tradition warns that a woman was sent to Hell for imprisoning a cat, neither feeding it nor letting it fend for itself.²⁶ These teachings establish a clear and non-negotiable ethical standard: the mistreatment of animals is a major sin in Islam.²⁵

4.2 The Reality of Caged Production: A Violation of Tayyib Principles

The commercial production of Kopi Luwak stands in stark violation of these Islamic principles. Investigations by animal welfare organizations like PETA and World Animal Protection, as well as academic researchers and journalists, have documented systemic and severe cruelty.⁶ The evidence reveals a litany of abuses:

• Inhumane Confinement: Civets are snatched from the wild and imprisoned in tiny, barren wire-mesh cages that prevent natural movement and behavior.⁶
• Unsanitary Conditions: The animals are often forced to live in their own filth, with inadequate cleaning protocols, increasing the risk of disease.²⁹
• Psychological Trauma: The extreme stress of confinement leads to zoochosis, a neurotic condition where animals exhibit abnormal behaviors like incessant pacing, circling, and self-mutilation.⁶
• Malnutrition and Disease: In captivity, civets are fed an unnatural, forced diet almost exclusively of coffee cherries, leading to nutritional deficiencies, fur loss, infections, and a high mortality rate.⁴

This process, defined by the torture and suffering of a living creature, cannot be considered tayyib. The resulting product, born from such immense cruelty, is fundamentally devoid of the “goodness” and “wholesomeness” required for consumption by a Muslim.

4.3 Haram li Ghayrih: When a Lawful Act Becomes Forbidden

Islamic jurisprudence contains the principle of haram li ghayrih, which means something that is permissible in its essence (halal li-dhatihi) can become forbidden due to an associated external factor or sinful act.³¹ For example, stolen water, while inherently pure and permissible, becomes forbidden to drink because it was obtained through the sin of theft.

This principle applies directly to caged Kopi Luwak. A coffee bean is, in itself, a halal plant product. However, when it is produced through a process that involves the systematic torture and abuse of animals—acts that are unequivocally sinful in Islam—the final product becomes tainted by that sin. The cruelty of the process renders the coffee haram li ghayrih.³¹ The ethical failure is so profound that it overrides any technical arguments about the bean’s ritual purity.

4.4 Consumer Deception: The Pervasive Issue of Fraud and Mislabeling

The ethical problem is compounded by widespread deception. Investigations have repeatedly shown that producers knowingly mislabel coffee from caged, abused civets as “wild-sourced” to appeal to ethically-minded consumers.⁶ Farmers have admitted that producing commercially viable quantities of exclusively wild Kopi Luwak is nearly impossible.⁶ This systemic fraud means that even a consumer attempting to make an ethical choice is likely to be deceived into supporting animal cruelty. This lack of transparency highlights a critical failure in the Halal certification process, which often focuses on ingredients and ritual slaughter but neglects the equally important Islamic principles of animal welfare and ethical sourcing.

---

5: Synthesis and Recommendations for the Conscious Consumer

Reconciling the technical legal rulings with the overwhelming ethical evidence provides a clear path forward for the Muslim consumer questioning the permissibility of Kopi Luwak.

5.1 Reconciling the Rulings: A Multi-layered Conclusion

From a purely technical jurisprudential perspective, the status of Kopi Luwak is ambiguous. A majority of Sunni scholars in the primary producing nations have deemed it permissible, but this permissibility is contingent on strict, often unverifiable conditions regarding the bean’s physical state and the thoroughness of its cleaning.⁹ This view is strongly contested by other reputable scholars and the entire Shi’a school of thought, who consider the product to be irredeemably impure.⁹ This conflict of opinions places Kopi Luwak squarely in the category of

shubuhat (doubtful matters). The Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) advised believers to avoid such matters to protect their faith and honor, making abstention the most religiously prudent course of action.

5.2 The Overwhelming Ethical Obstacle

The technical debate over ritual purity is largely overshadowed by the catastrophic failure of the Kopi Luwak industry to meet the Islamic ethical standard of tayyib. The evidence of animal cruelty is not anecdotal or isolated; it is a systemic, foundational feature of the commercial production model that has emerged to meet global demand.³¹ The confinement, abuse, and suffering inflicted upon civets are a direct violation of the Islamic ethos of mercy and compassion towards all of God’s creation.²⁵ Through the principle of

haram li ghayrih, this inherent cruelty renders the final product forbidden, regardless of its physical state.

5.3 Practical Guidance for the Muslim Consumer

Based on this comprehensive analysis, the following guidance is offered:

• Primary Recommendation: Avoidance. The most ethically sound, spiritually cautious, and religiously defensible position is to avoid Kopi Luwak entirely. The high probability of supporting an industry built on systemic animal cruelty, the significant risk of consuming a fraudulently labeled product, and the unresolved jurisprudential doubt make it an unacceptable choice for a conscientious Muslim.
• On Seeking “Ethical” Kopi Luwak: The only theoretically acceptable form of Kopi Luwak would be that which is 100% sourced from the droppings of wild, free-roaming civets. However, given the prevalence of fraud and the lack of a truly reliable and rigorous certification system that can guarantee a cage-free supply chain through unannounced audits, finding such a product is practically impossible.²⁸
• A Call to Action: The true Islamic response to the Kopi Luwak issue is not to seek a legal loophole for consumption, but to actively oppose the injustice inherent in its production. Consumers can align their actions with the highest principles of their faith by refusing to purchase the product and by raising awareness about the animal suffering it causes. In doing so, they affirm the Islamic values of mercy, justice, and compassion for all living creatures.

Cited Works

1. Kopi luwak – Wikipedia, accessed July 12, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kopi_luwak
2. What is Kopi Luwak?, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.kayakopi.com/what-is-kopi-luwak
3. en.wikipedia.org, accessed July 12, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kopi_luwak#:~:text=Production,-An%20Asian%20palm&text=Kopi%20luwak%20is%20brewed%20from,%2C%20enzymatic%2C%20and%20fermentation%20treatment.
4. The truth behind the world’s most famous coffee – The Civet Project, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.thecivetproject.com/post/the-truth-behind-the-world-s-most-famous-coffee-civet-coffee
5. How Civet Make World Most Expensive Coffee – Civet Coffee Farming – Coffee Harvest and Processing – YouTube, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ox7dQO-7Gss
6. Civets Suffering for Cruel Coffee – PETA, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.peta.org/features/civets-suffering-cruel-coffee/
7. Digested Civet Coffee Beans (Kopi Luwak)—An Unfortunate Trend in Specialty Coffee Caused by Mislabeling of Coffea liberica? – PMC, accessed July 12, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8228563/
8. AHF Halal Standards – American Halal Foundation, accessed July 12, 2025, https://halalfoundation.org/ahf-halal-standards/
9. IRSYAD AL-FATWA SERIES 142: The Ruling of Drinking Luwak Coffee (Civet Coffee), accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.muftiwp.gov.my/en/artikel/irsyad-fatwa/irsyad-fatwa-umum-cat/1865-irsyad-al-fatwa-series-142-the-ruling-of-drinking-luwak-coffee-civet-coffee
10. IRSYAD AL-FATWA SERIES 142: The Ruling of Drinking Luwak Coffee (Civet Coffee) – Federal Territories Mufti Office, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.muftiwp.gov.my/en/artikel/irsyad-fatwa/irsyad-fatwa-umum-cat/1865-irsyad-al-fatwa-ke-142-apakah-hukum-meminum-kopi-luwak?templateStyle=17
11. Ruling on Consuming Luwak Coffee | Halal Inspection Authority, accessed July 12, 2025, https://halalmui.org/hukum-mengkonsumsi-kopi-luwak/
12. The Commercialisation of Halalan Tayyiban Luwak Coffee – al-Qanatir, accessed July 12, 2025, http://al-qanatir.com/aq/article/download/454/361/2000
13. I. Najasat & Taharat | The Ritual and Spiritual Purity | Al-Islam.org, accessed July 12, 2025, https://al-islam.org/ritual-and-spiritual-purity-sayyid-muhammad-rizvi/i-najasat-taharat
14. Najis (Ritually Unclean) Things in Islam – The Zahra Trust, accessed July 12, 2025, https://zahratrust.com/islamic-resources/ahkam/najis-ritually-unclean-things/
15. Detailed Explanation on the Halal Ruling Regarding Spitting in Halal Food, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.halalcs.org/ruling-on-spitting-in-halal-food
16. Detailed Halal Sanitation Guidelines and Checklist for Manufacturers, accessed July 12, 2025, https://halalfoundation.org/halal-sanitation-guidelines-and-checklist/
17. Unifying Halal Product Certification: ASEAN’s Challenge – Fulcrum.sg, accessed July 12, 2025, https://fulcrum.sg/unifying-halal-product-certification-aseans-challenge/
18. IRSYAD HUKUM KE-142: Ruling on Drinking Luwak Coffee – Federal Territories Mufti Office, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.muftiwp.gov.my/ms/artikel/irsyad-hukum/umum/1865-irsyad-al-fatwa-ke-142-apakah-hukum-meminum-kopi-luwak
19. Can Muslims Drink Kopi Luwak?, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.purekopiluwak.com/can-muslims-drink-kopi-luwak/
20. Ruling on Drinking Coffee Extracted from the Feces of Civet Cats – Islam Q&A, accessed July 12, 2025, https://islamqa.info/en/answers/263239
21. Is Coffee Halal or Haram: Sorting Fact from Fiction, accessed July 12, 2025, https://fnb.coffee/blog/is-coffee-halal-or-haram/
22. ‘Cat Coffee’ Gets Halal Green Light – YouTube, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0pajB4g3Q6Q
23. The Controversy Surrounding the Halal Status of Kopi Luwak and Its Economic Business Development Opportunities, accessed July 12, 2025, https://halalin.walisongo.ac.id/index.php/halalin/article/view/4
24. Is It Allowed to Consume Luwak Coffee? | Ask A Question – Al-Islam.org, accessed July 12, 2025, https://al-islam.org/ask/is-it-allowed-to-consume-luwak-coffee
25. Religion and Animal Welfare—An Islamic Perspective – PMC, accessed July 12, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5332932/
26. The Ethical Treatment of Animals – Khaleafa, accessed July 12, 2025, http://www.khaleafa.com/khaleafacom/the-ethical-treatment-of-animals
27. Civet Coffee | Past Campaign | World Animal Protection, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.worldanimalprotection.org/our-campaigns/past-campaigns/civet-coffee/
28. KOPI LUWAK – WSPA International: The Cruelty Behind the World’s Most Expensive Coffee, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.comunicaffe.com/kopi-luwak-wspa-international-cruelty-behind-worlds-expensive-coffee/
29. Civet Coffee: The Rising Animal Welfare Crisis of Southeast Asia, accessed July 12, 2025, https://wildwelfare.org/civet-coffee-crisis/
30. Kopi Luwak Controversy: PETA Uncovers Animal Cruelty in Coffee Trade, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.foodingredientsfirst.com/news/kopi-luwak-controversy-peta-uncovers-animal-cruelty-in-coffee-trade.html
31. Income Analysis of Kopi Luwak from the Halalan Tayyiban Perspective – ResearchGate, accessed July 12, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328918321_ANALISIS_PENGHASILAN_KOPI_LUWAK_DARI_PERSPEKTIF_HALALAN_TAYYIBAN
32. Our Commitment to 100% Wild Kopi Luwak Sourcing, accessed July 12, 2025, https://gayokopi.com/our-commitment/